How Anthony Ippolito Landed the Role of Sylvester Stallone in ‘I Play Rocky’

Backstage November 16, 2026 18:51 Auditions Acting Self Tape

Casting director Rick Montgomery explains how Anthony Ippolito won the young Sylvester Stallone in I Play Rocky with a self-made tape of four scenes, and what he looks for in every actor.

9 Things Actors Should Know About Casting a Real-Life Icon

Drawn from what is actually said on camera, so you can decide whether to spend the 18:51 watching it.

Six weeks of searching ended with one agent call

Montgomery sent the script coast to coast, read actor after actor, and even approached waiters who looked like Stallone, figuring the odds were 50/50 they acted. About six weeks in, a trusted agent called and said she had his guy. That call came from a relationship, not a submission pile.

Ippolito taped four scenes nobody asked for

Anthony Ippolito picked four scenes from the script on his own and put them on tape. Two of them were scenes Montgomery was already using in auditions. The tape showed vulnerability, comedy and anger, and Montgomery says he instantly knew he had struck gold.

Cast the reality, close to the look

With legends like Carl Weathers to fill, the goal was to get as close to the real look as possible while keeping the same reality-based acting Ippolito brought. Montgomery wanted a feeling close enough to motivate the other actors, not an impression.

Calling the casting director shows you did the homework

Before a reading for director Peter Farrelly, Montgomery tells agents the actor may call him to talk it through. Anne Sophia did, with probing questions about her character, and the four-actress session ended in a unanimous choice for her.

Every face in his films is distinct on purpose

Montgomery avoids casting two actors with the same hair, height and build, because on a fast-moving script audiences confuse them. For this 1970s period piece the brief was simply great faces, great characters and great actors.

Show your choices, not your guess at the director's

His best advice for leaving a lasting impression: show your best work and make your best choices. Do not worry about what the director wants. He says casting is looking for your choices, and Farrelly loves actors who enhance the page.

Acting Craft is built by Web For Actors, who also wrote the 85 things casting directors and coaches say about auditions, which draws on videos like this one.

Was this helpful?

Yes 0 No 0

Sign in with Web For Actors to vote.

Full transcript (2,746 words)
Well, hi. I'm Jacqueline Tines with Backstage. And I'm here today with Rick Montgomery, the casting director for I Play Rocky. [music] Rick, thanks for joining us. [music] - Thank you so much. - Well, I loved the film. I especially loved its unique casting story. So, let's start there. Talk to me how did you find our young Sylvester Stallone? - When we started the project, casting directors normally always start to send out scripts and let the world know or every agent that you can everywhere, coast to coast, started getting scripts and people were reading it. And it's a wonderful, wonderful script. Just fantastic when you read it. So, uh I was getting responses and looking for that guy for Stallone. It was very difficult. Uh you know, it's like it has to look like Stallone. Uh to the point that you know, I'm getting submissions. I'm getting uh pictures from agencies of of their of their actor and trying to work it. And I was meeting actors and reading actors and uh even to the point of if I was in a restaurant and I figured I had a 50/50 shot uh if there was an waiter or someone like that who was working there might be right. If they look like Stallone, they might be an actor. I would approach him and ask. I had a few people read that way. Um nonetheless, about 6 weeks into the process, uh I got a call from Anthony's agent and said, I've got your guy. And she was a very trusted agent friend of mine. So, she sent it to me. And sure enough, Anthony put together four scenes on his own. He had picked four scenes from the script. And two of those scenes I was already using in my efforts in in auditioning. So um I was, you know, astounded with his talent. Uh it was so based in reality. Uh he showed vulnerability. He showed comedy. Uh he showed anger. Uh yeah he he just showed all the emotions. And instantly I knew I had struck gold. I mean it was just any casting director you'll talk to will tell you the same. Sometimes that person just walks in and blows you away and you know that's it. Instinctively you know that's the guy. So that was it with Anthony. I sent to Pete and Pete said the same. We found him. This is great. So - kissed that. - [laughter] - Yeah yeah it really was. I mean on top of it it's just like the sweetest nicest guy you'd ever want to meet. He's really a great So it even made the whole process even that much more, right? And then that's when I got to know him and it's like it was wonderful because it helped me understand his character and then, you know, what I had to do to find the rest of the cast. - What do you think an actor can learn from Anthony's self quote unquote self tape? - Boy um I think what you learn is that again it's about hard work. Uh Anthony worked on that. I mean that was not uh you know he read he read a scene and just did it. He obviously labored on that that tape and made it as fantastic as he absolutely could and as perfect as he could. And I think it's just that um for all actors. I think it's about your work ethic and really going for it and knowing But he also with Anthony it's you know that was heaven sent. Cuz he looks like Stallone or you know and he was he was his hair was growing out. So yeah I mean he really he he was really playing the part well. - I know you have to kind of do a double take sometimes when you're watching the film and you're like oh. - [laughter] - It's so much fun. - Uh well there's a joke in I Play Rocky about actors always lying about being able to do a skill like boxing or ice skating in order to land a role. How often do you see that happening when you're casting? - Oh. Not too often. [laughter] But it's true. I mean all actors would tell you if somebody said Can you ride a horse? Yeah you say yeah I can ride a horse. Cuz you figure you can you know you can go to the stable and somebody can teach you to to ride if you know when you have to prove it. So uh - always learn on the job. - Yeah yeah. - Well along with Stallone you also had to cast well-known legends like Carl Weathers. What was your philosophy for finding actors who could capture a real essence without slipping just into an impression? - Well that was just it. That that was the hard part. Because these are all such iconic characters in cinema. And it was very important for me to get as close as I could to their look at the same time with the same reality-based work that I we already saw from Anthony. So and I'm thinking about Kiki who played Tellus Sefon James. Sefon I had really been looking for Carl Weathers and and I hadn't I just I hadn't found it and I I'd talked to and a there was a lot of guys and couple of good friends of mine who I would have loved to put in the film, but I got a call one day from Stefan's manager and he was the one that said, hey, what do you think of Stefan for the role? And it's like, are you kidding me? He'd be perfect. I I didn't think he was, you know, he would I didn't think I didn't think the role was big enough. I I I don't know. I I it just was oh, no, no, we he really likes it. So I was so excited and he actually went so he did a reading. And we all liked him number one. And then he did this reading for Pete. And oh, it was so good. It was so good. Unbelievably good. - What advice would you give to an actor trying to land a role as a well-known star or icon? - If you look like the actor, then obviously like Anthony, Anthony knew that he looked enough like Stallone and that he obviously put some work into it, developed the voice, developed the style, and you know, I think I think those are just still the essential building blocks for any actor as they create these characters. So whether it's an iconic somebody or it's just you know, a wonderful character in a script. - Well, I play Rocky deals heavily with Hollywood rejection and studio executives looking for bankable over unknowns. Did working on the film make you reflect how the industry evaluates or maybe appreciates fresh talent today? - Oh, definitely. It's kind of a dream come true for any casting director if you just can cast whoever you really love. Um, and that's kind of um I guess the creative license we took on this that uh we were able to put all of our favorite people um you know it didn't if they didn't have to be a major movie star. And uh that that that's the difference. And every one of these actors um the other thing that I like to do is is each one of these actors were unique. And I try to do that in most of the films that I cast that everyone uh from the smallest role to the major roles um everyone has their own look. Nobody you know no one's going to look the same. Sometimes in movies uh there'll be a guy has got dark hair and then there's another guy with dark hair and they're about the same height and the same build and depending on the script and how fast it moves it can be confusing. So um I think that's the one thing I I love about this that everybody was so unique into themselves. Um yeah. - I know I have to say that the cast also really fit that 1970s vibe. What were you looking for when casting this type of period piece? - Great faces, great characters and great actors because look once we had Anthony um and then uh Sasha let's can we talk about Sasha? - Yeah yeah definitely. - So Sasha um we picked Pete and I picked four women, four actresses that we thought would really that were wonderful actresses and you know people know them uh in the business. And we met with all four and and then they read and they auditioned for the role. Uh and it was just Pete and I and uh Anne Sophia she had the dialect worked out. Um she looked like the actual Sal Sal Stallone. Blonde hair, cute, petite. There was a lot of similarities there. So and I I didn't have to hit it right on with her. I just wanted the feeling to be close enough that it it motivated Anthony. And he felt he was and and her as well. And she auditioned and when we were done reading all four of the women it was Pete and I we it was unanimous. I mean we instantly knew it was was her. She just she also worked really hard. Um whenever we have a reading in front of Pete um I always tell the actors uh their agents that if the actor wants to call me and talk about it I'll I'll be happy to. Uh Anne Sophia definitely took care of that and called me and we spoke and she had very probing questions about her and her character and so she I knew she was doing all her homework. And there we are again. You know, we're back to actors. Actors really working hard, doing their homework. She really wanted the job and it showed in her work. I mean is she amazing in the movie? - I loved the moment in the car. I was like I was like - was fantastic. - Oh god. - The uh the P in the pod it that's so subtle. - Yeah. - quiet and so beautiful. Such a beautiful little scene that Pete crafted there, really. Just special. - Well, - I often ask casting directors if they know about the smartphone face concept. It's basically the idea that actors today maybe look a little too modern for a time period because they look like they've seen an iPhone. Do you think a smartphone face plays a factor into casting? - Um sure in a way, but then you know, right? That it's about hair, makeup, wardrobe. I mean, that has a whole lot to do with it. - Well, you're also a long-time collaborator uh with Pete and his brother working on projects like Green Book and even Dumb and Dumber. What is your working relationship like with Pete? - Yeah, it's fantastic. I am the luckiest one of the luckiest guys in the world or at least in Hollywood to have met Pete fairly when he was just starting and and you know, I cast Dumb and Dumber for him and uh and he's been my uh ally and partner and mentor and just a hell of a good friend for all these years and uh I can't say enough great things about Pete. I mean, he he's almost defined my career. When you look at I Play Rocky, Green Book uh Dumb and Dumber and Let's Something About Mary, a worldwide hit. I mean, those four films sort of envelop my career. That That is my career. Um I've done a lot of other movies obviously, but and working with Pete is just, you know, one of my favorite things to do in the world. I I just I care so much about the guy and it's so much fun creatively working with him. And he always makes it fun. He He's not He's not He's just a great guy. He's just a great guy and he's silly on the phone sometimes and I mean, he he he's a very serious guy and a very very smart man. But uh but he he he he likes to keep things loose and I think that it shows in the films and any actor that works with Pete wants to work with him all the time. Everybody wants to work with him because not only of his talent but just of his personality and how he runs a set and uh he's just you know I can go on and on about Pete Farrelly. He's the best. He is just the absolute best. - Also lovely just looking at your resume and how how much you've worked together it seems like a really good working relationship. - just I'm so lucky. So lucky. - of Dumb and Dumber uh it's known that Jeff Daniels kind of had a Stallone situation where New Line offered him a low salary so he'd hopefully walk away. Do you remember like the moment you knew that his chemistry with Jim Carrey would work? - I do remember that. Um I don't remember the deal making process but uh no he had uh I knew he was living in Michigan at the time and his hair had grown out and he was playing a lot of golf um and uh he came in looking just like he did in Dumb and Dumber. And uh he auditioned with Jim. Jim was there in the room and the two of them read and uh and and and we just it was so good and Jeff was so good and Jim loved we all loved him. I mean it was just but that was you know that was a long time ago and we were actually in the room all of us together and it it really made it it it was just again very obvious that he was really the right guy for it. - I definitely grew up with those 90s and early 2000 hits. Can you name an audition that still sticks with you and why those early days? - Um, well, I mean, there's so many when I when when I start to think about it, really. I mean, um, Eva Mendez, um, you know, just there I can go on and I mean, I it's just like on almost every picture. We're always finding new people and that's kind you know, it's just always been that way. Um, so no, I don't have any one special story. I have many, many, many stories. - For an actor trying to leave a lasting impression with a casting director like yourself, what's your best advice for them? - Um, show me your best work. Make your best choices. Um, don't worry about what the director's choices are. That's one thing actors always, you know, what's the director looking for? Um, we're looking for your choices. Um, you know, Pete is a very collaborative guy. He likes when actors if they can enhance with Paige by their performance and what they do or might say, he loves that. I mean, and that's what makes it grounded and more real. And here I am the guy talking about, you know, we do all these broad comedies, but it's uh or have. Um, but it's still all rooted in the same place. So always grounded. I think that those are the best things for any young actor. - Well, just to wrap things up, I Play Rocky is definitely generating some Oscar buzz. Do you think the new award for casting has changed the audition room at all? - No. Not for me. So I think it's uh I'm I'm thrilled um for all of us. I'm thrilled for all of us that we we could be recognized on at that scale. And uh I I think that's wonderful. I think it's wonderful and David Rubin and a lot of the people that worked a long time to get that done um you know hats off to those guys. - [music]