Denée Benton on advocating for Peggy from her audition onward, stage versus screen, researching a period role, and the unspoken class system of the industry.
9 Things Actors Should Know From Denée Benton on The Gilded Age
Drawn from what is actually said on camera, so you can decide whether to
spend the 23:53 watching it.
You can advocate for a character from the audition
Benton began pushing for Peggy to be more than the footnote Black characters often are in period drama when she auditioned in 2019. Four years later the Black elite world takes up far more of the show than anyone planned, and she can trace it to every email, call and meeting.
Learn to push back respectfully, assertively and collaboratively
She says the creative team could easily have told her to be quiet and get to work. Instead the conversations became mutual education, and she credits both her own courage and their respect for her as an artist. The skill she learned was how to raise stereotypes in a way that kept the door open.
Doing School Girls on Broadway eight times a week, she quotes John David Washington saying theater is the only thing that hits his body the way football did. On stage you muscularly craft the whole journey yourself. On set you sustain your energy over long days and trust others to capture and edit a moment you may never know landed.
Two characters can share a spirit and differ in tactics
She sees Peggy and her Broadway role Paulina as spiritually alike: both claim space where people say they do not belong. What separates them is the tactic each uses to get there, which is where she builds the difference.
To us Peggy reads as a classy, polished figure. In her own time she was taboo and radical, a Black woman doing something considered masculine by having a professional point of view. Benton plays her as someone who knows how risky her path is and chooses it anyway.
Let a respectable character be ambitious and petty too
Respectability politics is its own cage, she says. She loves that Peggy does not spend every scene morally teaching people, and gets to have ambitions, eye rolls and tension with the women William was supposed to want.
She studied Ida B. Wells and read Black newspapers of the period to learn what people were talking about. That research fed a real story change: Peggy was first going to write under a pseudonym for a white paper, and instead writes for the Black newspapers that actually existed.
Advocate for who is behind the camera, not just the story
What began as Benton, one Black director and a historical consultant grew into three Black women executive producers and a Black woman in the writers room. That freed her to simply be an actor, and gave her a view of how production works that few season one actors get.
A show that pays for a publicist, a stylist and the events is its own class structure, and some actors get a second chance at that first round while others drop off the list. She tells of an Emmy nominated friend advised by a casting director to let people keep thinking she was British. Her answer is to be ready: her classical training is what let her step into Peggy.
I'm so happy about the season, and you know, getting to see your journey from season 1 to season 4 and we've talked about this and you know, having seen I think the first two episodes, everyone in the room: Peggy really comes to the forefront here right, in this, in this season in a way that is really fantastic and special. So, I'd love to hear, you know, going into this season and now, you know, experiencing with everybody, what is that like for you, you know, having been on this journey for so long that it's like it's kind of Peggy's moment this period. No, it's really special. It feels sacred. Um, you know, when I got cast in 2019, I think with big ensemble shows, you always sort of have different seasons cycle through kind of who's in the center. season. It's definitely the next generation kind of stepping forward. Um, but I also when I auditioned for the role really got to advocate for Peggy being more than a footnote that, you know, black characters tend to be in traditional period drama shows. Like, you know, it's really blip instead of its own universe. And I just really felt like even with the intention to have her be a part of this class discussion we hadn't had before, there were still like a lot of stereotypes that were making it into story. And so I really got to learn as an actor how to have those conversations like respectfully, assertively, collaboratively. And it's uh a tribute to like my courage and also a tribute to the respect that the creative team had for me as an artist that they were willing to also engage me because they very much could have said be quiet girl and get to work or don't.
And instead there really got to be conversations like mutual passion education. And now four years later, I don't think anyone had intended for the black elite world to take up as much space and screen time as it has. And I can really see like every email, phone call, meeting that went into that. So, it's special creatively like to have affected pop culture that way. And then for me as just an actor in an industry that's going through so much change and scarcity to get to shine in this way and like really show my range is not something I take for granted. Well, speaking of showing your range really beautiful. We got a tea for you because Thank you y'all. I'm on Broadway. My throat's dry. Yeah. If you weren't aware, while also doing Press for Gilded Age, Da is also starring in School Girls or the African Mean Girls Play on Broadway right now. And let's talk about range because the character that you play on Broadway, you know, eight times a week is wildly different than Peggy.
And I just think it's so I think for actors, you know, I think, you know, there's theater and there's movies and there's TV and, you know, people wonder about do you calibrate your performances differently for the different mediums and whatnot. I would love to hear if you approach your work, you know, on stage and, you know, specifically what you're doing right now the same way that you approach your work on the Gilded Age and like how do you craft a character? You know, I feel like Peggy and Paulina spiritually have a lot in common. Okay. They just have like different tactics about going about claiming space somewhere where people have told them they don't deserve it and they are really ravenous about not having that be the end of the story. And then I think technique-wise being on stage is just like physically going to war. No shade to people who've actually been to war, but for those of us who like frolic for a living, it more than frolic. Yeah, it is a lot on the system. And you know, someone came to see the show, the Washingtons came, the Queen Paula Washington and John David Washington. Okay. and he used to play football and he said theater is the only thing that hits him in the same place that playing football did with how much it asks of your body and that was just so validating cuz the way we hobble oh my god those stairs to our dressing rooms it's just like a different it's like a sprint whereas being on set is more like figuring out how to kind of stay in a long form marathon with your experience and it's kind of you're trusting people to capture lightning in bottle that you don't even necessarily know if it landed or how it landed and how they're going to edit it. But on stage, you really get to muscularly craft a journey.
Um, so fantastic. And then you have to figure out how to sustain it and not get the plague. Not get the plague. No plank to have as much tea as you want. I will literally plug if you have if any opportunity to go see the show before November 15th. I think you got to go see it. It's absolutely brilliant performance and they're live streaming the final week of performances so you can watch from home and tell your friends and buy a ticket that way too. Double showing Guilded Age School Girls. Boom. It's fantastic. You got to do it. I So to circle back to the to the Guild Age and what you just said about the Black Elite, which is something that I like I found so fascinating that I think a lot of people don't understand about, you know, any marginalized group is that they think we're a monolith.
We're seeing even in episode two, there are fissures and fractions in the black elite that Peggy is has to navigate. Absolutely. Thank you. Um I would love to hear, you know, because it's you have you and your mother on the show, Audrey McDonald, sort of coming, you know, sorry, who? Six time Tony winner Audrey McDonald. Let's give it up for her. Coming, you know, going headto-head in, you know, a polite way with Felicia Rashad and, you know, the Newport scene. I just I would love to know, especially since you had a hand in, sort of, you know, crafting or, you know, collaborating in that what, you know, what that was like, sort of navigate... oh, like Peggy, you know? She's from this sort of Black world in Brooklyn, but that doesn't mean she's going to be accepted in Newport. I mean I love it. I love any opportunity to like share the truth of how dynamic humans are you know and the realities that I love a black anti-hero.
I love a black villain. You know, like I love getting to cuz in a way respectability politic is its like own cage. And so I think it's really thrilling to not have Peggy's every scene just be her like morally teaching people how to be good, but to be like really inside of her own ambitions and her own eye rolls at this woman who doesn't respect her. And what I really love about season 2 and season 3 is not even just the dynamic between Peggy and Mrs. Kirkland, but between Peggy and all of the women that William was supposed to want. Yes. You know, the people that were that were chosen, you know, all the Yeah. All the young light-skinned girls that are like, "You right? Oh my god." Scandalous. Exactly. And it's really fun to play into all of that tension and kind of remember that, from our vantage point, Peggy is this, like, you know, classy Black Barbie. But in her time, she was really taboo and really radical, and wouldn't even have been considered a woman in many spaces because of not only her Blackness, but because she's doing something so masculine by having a professional point of view.
Yeah. Um, and so I try to treat her that way that like she understands like how risky the walk is that she's walking and chooses it anyway cuz she's lost so much. Yeah. Well, I mean, speaking of that, like this episode gets into with the respectability politics and felad sort of, you know, erasing a part of your history, you know, a really painful part of your history and whatnot and a painful part of Peggy's history, I should say. um and rewriting it to sort of fit into this mold of what she thinks will you know play better necessarily um with her constituents if you will. I, I would love to know I guess thinking about something that and I always got mad at this critique of the show back in the day where it was like, "Oh, like nothing really happens, like it's about Christine Baransky crossing the street." And it's like, "Oh, there's so much; like, Peggy's been through hell and back for seasons and seasons." I would love to... cross the borders baby. Exactly. I guess. Yeah. I, you know, drawing on sort of the more it's tonally such an tricky and fantastic show where it's like so light and it feels like a warm bath, but also there's trauma and like real history and real pathos there. So, I guess how do you navigate that as an actress?
I'm really honored to get to be one of the like more grounded heartbeats of the show in that way. Um, and wait, what was the first part of the question? Oh, just holding the the the light tone with like actual real like historical trauma that your character has been through. I think it's interesting because during this time in American history, a lot of the ways that you moved up wise was by erasing your history, right? Like those who have come to be known as white were once indigenous to somewhere else. But Bertha in season one, you know, she doesn't want to be known as a potato digger's daughter. You know, Jack is hiding who he is. And so to have Peggy decide that she's going to rise through class by still placing herself in um her indigenous history and the amount of generations that have been through it is sort of radical in and of itself. And I think about that now. Obviously that kind of separation from any sense of place is like why all of the people who were actually immigrants to this country get to call people that are native to this native to this land the immigrants you know like when you think about who's native to like actual Turtle Island and the three land masses those are the people that we're deporting somewhere when it's really Europeans you know came here yeah a lot of that kind of ideology was really cemented during this time period. And so to have a character that's like, you know, and to have someone like who's playing my father, John Douglas Thompson, incredible legend. Um, but represent a narrative of a family that's deciding to move move on up while staying connected to the fact that like their people came from somewhere else than this particular land in New York.
And I think that's really special. Yeah. Wow. That's so well said. So wonderful. The show kind of gets to be like a high elevated like PBS history lesson. I'm like with them like erasing history in schools. Maybe Gilden Age is all we'll have left. I know to educate the children. Truly. It's like we need we actually have it. I I guess I would love to know how much Yeah.
How much like actual research did you do? I I know it's been years now, but like you know what what yet what historical research did you do when crafting Peggy and you know were there specific people or like you know that you were looking to or sort of Yeah, I would love to know. Yeah, I thought a lot about ID Wells who was like a writer and activist at that time who you know it's interesting our show is definitely more of a polished version of that time but like Idb Wells was like teaching people how to use guns. She was like, "If someone confronts you on the street, this is how you do it." You know, and so I think Peggy was consuming a lot of radical text that way. I read a lot of black newspapers at that time to figure out like what they were talking about and the issues were and also that was a part of us advocating for more stories. Originally in season 1, Peggy was going to write for a white newspaper and write under a pseudonym. And Dr. Erikica Dumbar, our incredible um co-executive producer and historical consultant, was uh a part of bringing in this alternative option to have her write for these newspapers that really did exist and were a part of teaching, you know, um newly emancipated people how to read and create new spaces and and talk about politically what was happening across the country. So those moments, but I think really for me less than advocating for specific story lines, it was also I got to really advocate for the infrastructure behind the scenes to support the, you know, dynamic stories we were trying to tell. So what was originally me, one black director, and Dr. Dumbar as a consultant, we were able to advocate for it to become three black women executive producers as well as a black woman on the writer room so that I could also just be Yeah. Give it up an artist.
And I got to really learn um just like the production side of things and kind of get a vantage point of how the sausage is made in a way that most season one actors on a show don't get to have. That's so fantastic. And yeah, I I commend you for that. Also, you know, not to pivot away from The Guilded Age once again, you have a fantastic movie that just got nominated for best feature at the Gotham Awards, Dreams and Nightmares, where I would love to know, you know, about your work on that cuz, you know, you just spoke about wearing different hats, being, you know, an artist and also, you know, working behind the scenes and, you know, producing and collaborating, whatnot. I know Dreams of Nightmares was a similar situation. So, how do you sort of wear two hats? Because it's it's it's hard enough just to act well, let alone be doing all of this work to make sure and shape a story. So, hearing about that on the Gilded Age, I would love to hear more about that and on Dreams and Nightmares, too. You know, I think honestly like one I come from a sort of experimental device theater space. That's sort of the way I was trained in school. And when I got to New York, I was doing a lot of like downtown things at Lama and always sort of being um like just a part of the creative body that's happening. Um and I did a lot of work with the team which is like a avanguard theater space.
Cool. Excuse me. But then on the other tip, like realistically as like a black actress, if you really want to rise through the different ranks of this game, there's so many levels to it and you just don't have the luxury to trust that people are going to bring to you what you deserve. And to learn it can kind of become like an obsessive psychosis. Like the anxiety of scarcity is so real because You realize, like, okay, like, people who have my same accolades or have my same positioning are getting invited into rooms a lot easier, or that's led to this brand opportunity that leads to more income for less labor, and all of these things that you're like, "Okay, am I crazy that that door is not opening?" And I think so. Having moments of momentum, there's, like, you know, you're this working actor, and then there are moments where you get kind of this momentum to rise through the class ranks of our industry, which, like, you're not really supposed to talk about. It's all so opaque, but it's so real. Like having a show that gives you the money to even invest in a publicist and a stylist and go to the events and do the game is its own kind of class structure that keeps certain people out. And then once you do, if you know, you don't do the first round right, some people are given another chance. Some people are just kind of like taken off the list. And I think that like these moments to get to star in an indie film um in incredible cinematography in this like whimsical narrative that's a combination of Away we go meets Waiting to Exhale meets the L Word. It's like so dynamic and it's so rare for any black American actress specifically to get that kind of opportunity.
But even Chitaara the filmmaker had to like beg, borrow and steal to really get any space in the room to get distribution, you know, while the reviews were comparable with any other canon queer film that's come out in the last decade on Rotten Tomatoes. Yeah. And so, you know, 100% of Rotten Tomatoes, Richard Brody, five stars, all the things. And it is exhausting to have to still strategize so much. I feel like any visible black American actress, you know, is like also a producer and could run a small country because of like how many how many transferable skills you have to learn how to use in order to get the same kind of momentum. And for me, it's all about like our our bodies are our work and our vessels. And so I see so many of my idols who have every accolade as their contemporaries still having to work so hard and still wondering if a director is going to call them or still being like I haven't taped it all this year. And I'm like you diva wa you this is psychological warfare. Yeah, that is unbelievable. And you know, I was watching Naomi Aki talk about it. She's sort of like, you know, no one really cares except for us. But it is very like validating, I think, to hear people say it out loud.
Um, and just the different hustle it takes. And I'm really passionate about it. And I hope every time I see like a younger actress coming up, I'm always like, "Okay, girl, this is what I learned because someone did it for me." You're getting big. I think a lot of people are learning literally right now. Yeah. And it's so nice that there's even though there is like a scarcity, you know, of of roles and opportunities, it really feels like you don't have a scarcity mindset and you're, you know, you were championing Even once you get the opportunity, what the star making vehicle is, you know? Because I'm in a place where I actually have really incredible opportunity, and it's, um, the behindthe-scenes navigating that it takes to make it recognizable within the industry for it to provide more access to either luxury spaces or to more projects or to be considered greenlightable. Like all of those things that I think the carpet gets rolled out in a different way for the same credits with a different demographic, you know, and you kind of have to prove every time. I'm like, we all saw Black Panther. We know we know we know that we can sell tickets just like it's all propaganda. It is all propaganda. But I mean, thinking of, you know, just hopefully people notice like the quality of the work, but also like I mean, the numbers don't lie.
Season 4, the premiere of the Guilden Age, the best view, the most views that it's had thus far. I think it was four million people watched it. I think it was 25% more than season 3, which was more than season 2. It's just growing and growing and growing. So, what's it feel like to be a part of a show that like, you know, you've been a part of it for six years, and it's still reaching new audiences. It's still growing. It's still there's still more ground to conquer, if you will. I'm so honored and thankful. I feel like I'm a part of the like best theater company on international television. Like behind the scenes and in front of the camera, it's like just crafts people at the highest peak of, you know, watching the way our wig department specifies over how a curl is going to be. It's like these are just artists in a time where like, you know, they're shoving AI down our throats. I feel like our show is like a love letter to human craftsmanship in a way.
Really? It really is. And I love that. I love that our show gets to be a part of what a slowburn looks like and giving art artists time to grow and time to bake and time, you know, to like have each season gather more like super fans. I also, you know, every season we thought it was our last. And so this season for us to be like, "Oh my god, I think we might kind of be a hit maybe, guys. I think I think I think and you know like constantly edging on a sense of security but that's sort of the actor's life but um Yeah, it's just, it's really special to me. It's sacred. I think that I just it's such rare air to be, not only to have like any kind of artistic stability, but to be a part of really shifting how culture views us and what we're capable of and the space we're able to take up you. So, this is like inside scoop tea. But you know there's always conversation around like the diaspora and how different actors are sort of put into the star making vehicle and you know they're always sort of pitting black American and black British actors against each other and all of these things and we're all sort of a part of the same diaspora. But I have a friend, a black American actress who is Emmy nominated, incredible, brilliant, gajillion followers, all of the ticks, right?
And she was meeting with a very prominent casting director who is a gatekeeper for many projects we would go in for. Okay. And she was like, "Oh, I didn't know you weren't British. Everyone thought you were British." And my friend was like, "No, no, I'm not." And she was like, "Well, keep it that way. Don't let people know you're not." And she was like, "Well, why?" And then she was like, "Come on, girl. What? What? You want to put on your little white t-shirt? You want to What? you want to play crackhead and I was like in the year of our lord 2026 that's still happening is this still happening And so, those moments it's crazy, like, you know, obviously that's such an extreme example. But the fact that it's like, "Oh, this person cast like so many things," and so when I see a character like Peggy and I get to really use the fact that, like, I'm classically trained and I got my check off skirt and I know how to move. check off skirt is you know you don't want to spend your life and artistic career like proving people wrong, but it feels like I got to step into something that was really designed for what I do well.
And you know, you can't really look at me or any of the actors on that screen and say that we don't have the range to embody so many different worlds. Oh, totally. Oh my gosh. Czechov's got to move over. It's checkup skirt now. I love that. I love that I got my check off skirt. Wow. I that I'm so that's been so wonderful and I just like your cander and your poise and your intelligence stress. Okay, we got to get thumbs up, so we're good. I didn't say any names. No names.
No names. I guess on that note, on a little spoiler, I know, you know, we got six more episodes left of the season. You know, a lot is going on for Peggy. What can you say, I guess, sort of to tease the audience about what's to come for Peggy's journey without giving anything away? You know, we really get to see Peggy face what it means to like run a household at that time. Once you get married, it is its own full-time job to like be the woman of the house in that way. And Peggy's just really focused on other things. Yeah. And we get to see her like you're busy. She's busy. Humbled, you know, when you know, William wants to throw a dinner party and Peggy's like, I have a speech to write. She's like, I got to She's like, now I got to make place cards.
I got to do this. I don't know how to cook. Uh, and she has this moment where we really get to honor the kind of labor that um, Mrs. Kirkland and Dorothy Scott and the women of that time really did to create entire productions and make it look seamless was such a skill. And then we get to see Peggy kind of really grapple with the blinders she has on and the kind of survival strategy she has of really obsessing over this mountaintop and how that balances with her husband who's dealing with his own glass ceilings, you know? And it was really cool to figure out how to walk the line of being like the enemy isn't each other. The en enemy is like the systems of this country that's making it so they can't both be their best selves in the same place. But um it feels like we get to really see Peggy like not always be such a princess in those moments which I love and I think is humanizing and important to see her be like I don't know sir I got somewhere to be and to have to kind of gather, you know, she gets gathered by the by the elders in ways that I think will be exciting for people to see. Oh well I for one can't wait. I am so excited. Oh my gosh. Well, give it up for D.
Bon star.
0 comments