Virginie Efira for ‘All of a Sudden’ | Conversations at the SAG-AFTRA Foundation

SAG-AFTRA Foundation November 18, 2026 32:22 Acting Training On Set

Virginie Efira on how Ryusuke Hamaguchi prepared her for All of a Sudden: flat readings, unseen scenes, 17 character questions and Japanese lines.

12 Things Actors Should Know About Working the Hamaguchi Way

Drawn from what is actually said on camera, so you can decide whether to spend the 32:22 watching it.

Heavy preparation is what buys you freedom on set

Efira says most filmmaking gets standardized, with no room left to breathe. Hamaguchi leaves room for the unexpected and trusts his actors to be free, but she stresses that you only get there by working a lot beforehand. The preparation is what lets you stay in the present and capture something alive.

Rehearse scenes that will never be in the film

Hamaguchi wrote and staged scenes outside the script, such as her character running into the husband she left years ago. The point was never to control a backstory. It was to give her real memories to draw on when she talked to that actor on camera.

Read the text flat, hundreds of times

Following the method seen in Drive My Car, the cast read their lines with no emotion and no acting, just speaking them, maybe 600 times at the start. Efira says the text gets embodied that way, and when you finally act it in front of the camera it feels like the text wakes up.

Answer the questions the script never asks

Hamaguchi gave her a document of 17 questions, written like a journalist interviewing the character: what matters to you in life, what is your relationship with sexuality. None of it was about the plot. She says it let her know the character's secrets.

Spend real time with the real world of the story

Preparation included workshops in a real nursing home with real residents, some of whom appear in the film beside actors. The residents did not really understand cut and kept calling her Marie-Lou, so she felt the movie carried on after each take ended.

Take the hard assignment when the chance is rare

Cast about two months before shooting, she had to learn her lines in Japanese, and Hamaguchi asked her to learn to read them too. She studied hiragana with a teacher and says she reads like an eight year old. Her view: if you get this kind of chance, you take it and you work.

Trying to do it well pulls you out of the moment

Takes ran up to 20 minutes, and a fluffed line meant starting over. Efira admits she was afraid at first, and that thinking 'I must do it well' is the wrong state for being present. She told herself to be kind to herself, look at her scene partner and stop thinking about herself.

Do not use your text like a tool

In the first week Hamaguchi told her, through an interpreter, that he wanted her to find the light, meaning to receive what is around her. He also told her to go inside the text instead of using it. He gives minimal direction and avoids psychological explanation: be in the present and project.

Find the language of the movie, not only of the character

Efira suggests looking for how the whole film speaks, not just how your character talks. Hamaguchi's work sits between a neutral, Bresson style and the Cassavetes style he admires. She says he has perfect pitch and can hear when you are not inside a scene.

Keep some choices to yourself

In a cigarette scene and a massage scene, she chose to play a thread of desire toward Tao Okamoto's character, even though the film is not about that. She never told Hamaguchi until a month after shooting. The film is the director's, she says, but the character's secret thoughts can be the actor's.

Let the real relationship do the work

The film shot close to chronologically, so she and Okamoto got to know each other as their characters did, and held back questions early on. The last scene shot was the ending, and she used the real knowledge that their time together was ending when she looked at her.

Listen to the character who disagrees with you

Efira says you look for what you share with a character, and she shares Marie-Lou's optimism and her habit of being sure she is right. What she values in the film is listening to someone who does not think like you, like the nurse Sophie, and finding what you have in common.

Acting Craft is built by Web For Actors, who also wrote what a class actually buys you, which draws on videos like this one.

Was this helpful?

Yes 0 No 0

Sign in with Web For Actors to vote.

Full transcript (4,483 words)
In the past decade, you've become one of the top European actors working with auteurs mainly from Europe, but now Japan as well. It's been an incredible path for you. I mean, you won a César for Revoir Paris, you won the Best Actress prize in Cannes for this film this year, shared with your co-star Tao Okamoto, and I think that my favorite film of yours, I have to say, okay, it's this one, but before this one, Rebecca Zlotowski's film, Other People's Children, your performance is incredible. If you haven't seen that film, please do yourselves a favor. It's an amazing movie. So, Ryosuke Hamaguchi, he is, you know, one of the most singular directors working today and one of the preeminent directors out of Japan, but particularly in his last three films, Drive My Car, Evil Does Not Exist, and now All of a Sudden, he has kind of confirmed himself as this master philosopher, storyteller, who has a very singular way of working, a very singular way of telling stories, and I just wonder, how much did you know of his work when the script came your way? I want to lie and to say, before meeting him, I saw all his movies, but, you know, I will say the truth. I only saw, first of all, excuse my English. It's not perfect. I try to do my best. It's great. It's better than my French. I understand you can do that. I don't understand anything at all, but I only saw Drive My Car before meeting him, but it was enough to say, oh, maybe it's the luck of my life, because I saw this movie, and this movie, you know, it's like something so radical and so extraordinary and so specific. Everything is inside. It's almost like a symphony, that film. Yes, yes. I find it completely shattering, devastating. And after I saw this movie, I heard, I saw this movie a few years before, but I heard my agent call me and say, oh, Amaguchi is in France, oh, and he wanted to make a movie in France, and he's interested in meeting you. Okay, great. And then after that, I read the script, and it's something very special, because Amaguchi, like you said before, is really a director of image. He knew what's cinema, what's the possibility of cinema, but in the script, there is already everything inside, like how to make some theoretical things, philosophical things, sociological things, political things, concrete and organic. And the path of emotion, and I like that, you don't, when you read it, you can say, oh, it's this way, or it's this way, the path of emotion, it comes suddenly. And after, when he make, the filming process with him is the same thing, because most of the time, or sometimes most of the times, filmmaking becomes standardized, a little bit standardized, and there's no room left for, to breathe, for breathing. No spontaneity. Yes, but Amaguchi, with Amaguchi, you're absolutely sure that there's a room left for unexpected things, for uncertainty. And then you can embrace the unpredictability of reality. And then the shooting becomes an adventure. It's not only the movie, but the shooting, the filming experience process, because he captures some reality. There's always with Amaguchi movie, a sensation of documentary. But it's cinema everywhere. How is it possible? And it's possible because he got faith in his actor. He let them free. But to go in this other world, you must be well prepared. It's like you, you work a lot before you make a, I will explain maybe if you're interested in it, the way you must be prepared. But after that, you really find the best condition to allow you to, to be free and to, to be, to capture alive things and to be in the present all the time. I understand that he rehearses some scenes which are never intended to be in the film, but give you your background, give you a sense of who your character is, and in a way, plant your character's memories in your head. But yes, he writes scene and we play, we act some scene before, scene that is not in the movie. Like with my colleague, we make a scene that a memory when I was married a long time ago, and I left my husband and I met him in the street and we speak. And it's like a memory that you can have in your head. It's not to control all my past backstories that, and then my character is like this. Never to control something, but it's to open your imagination. I have a reference. When I talk to him, I can have in my head some memories, real memories. I have that also with the resident that you saw in the movie. We shared things before with the real resident of, with the actors. Because when you saw a resident with cognitive trouble, it's an actor. And when it's less, not with big cognitive trouble, it's not an actor, it's a resident. What is the woman? It's always got a cigarette outside under the tree. I love that. I will share something. She's an incredible, she's an actress in, in life. And she plays a lot of, with very great, how do you say theatre director? She make a lot of things. And before shooting Amaguchi, he shows me her in work. And then we share that together with the actresses. Then we have, we already have this kind of relation before. I took down some, some things that I think the film is about. It's so multi-layered, so complex that, you know, it's about a million things, care and compassion, kindness and human dignity, death, altruism and capitalism, declining birth rates, labor shortages, healthcare with an aging population. So how would you define in its essence, this movie? If someone asks you, tell us what kind of movie is this? What do you say? In my language of in English, my language, I can say a lot of things. I don't know if you have the same thing that me, but I like when there's not a thematic movie. Oh, this movie is about this. Oh, it's better when it's more large. And sometimes also journalists say, can you give me the pitch of the movie? No, I can't. And it's good. If I say it's about the essence of life, does it mean really something, the essence of life? What is that? But it's, it's the way I feel it when I read it. If you don't know nothing about philosophy, you know, something it's learning to life and learning to life is knowing certainly that we're going to die. And maybe the beauty of life is because we're going to die. It's make sense. And maybe like I say, that's like, this is not so interesting, but this movie give you inside your heart, something like that. Okay. Yes, we're going to die. Okay. The world is now in America, in France, everywhere. Hey, hey, what's, what happened here? Capitalism. Goodbye. It's the end of the things. What are we? But we have maybe a solution and what is the solution? The other. Maybe we can save Earth like this. And Amaguchi is like this all the time. Humanity is in the movie, but is also with his actor is listen to the other. He's definitely one of our most humanistic contemporary filmmakers. Yes. And it's, I don't know what you think about that, but it's for me, it's so difficult to make a good movie with, with about human, about good feelings. Me, I only saw, I don't know if you're so charismatic. You know, you know, um, this movie tell you, if you make good things for the other, you will be better after. Oh yes. Thank you. Uh, but there's so much poetry inside, inside the movie. That's so huge. And for me, it's the same thing here. It makes the most sophisticated things and, but in a very simple way. And it's difficult to make a so big movie with this kind of feelings. It's more easy because maybe it's more lucid. I don't know to say system will win. You mentioned before, um, documentary. And to me, one of the things that really struck me about this film is his fascination with processes of work and whether it's a theater production in drive my car or a town hall meeting to protest an environmental develop, um, intrusion in evil does not exist or whether it's the running of an elder care facility facility in Paris here. So to me, that fascination with all the processes, the meetings, the conferences, the zoom calls, it felt almost like being in a Frederick Wiseman documentary, but also like a law on content film. I mean, a wonderful French director who I adored. That's true. That's true. I get the same feeling. It's always very interesting. Um, with them, I go, she, there was all the time, some meeting and workshop and even in, even his preparation, uh, before shooting in France, he make workshop with other French actors to know that, uh, uh, did the, well, yes, the sensation of documentary is something it's like, oh, to make theory, uh, oh, to, to come on, transform it, transform theory in physical things. Um, during the preparation, we have all this kind of workshop. I don't know to say, um, all the character who use you, many to things in the film, uh, to go courses of with and learn. And we make the rear. So in a real nursing home, we do that with real residents. We share everything. Um, before it was something special, but because when he say in Japanese, I like the sound action, oh, hi. And cuts after that, I, it's, I got a feeling that the movie continues, continue after cuts. It's like, because the residents are there and they don't understand really cut. They call me Marie Lou, even when I was, uh, Virginia, uh, I say, okay. And, and, um, there's this kind of thing. And also all the flat reading. I don't know if you saw drive my car, but you, there's a lot of thing about theater and we saw the actors rehearsal together and they make flat reading flat readings. You must read the text like, uh, without emotion, without any emotion, without acting really just, just, just speaking it and you do it maybe 600 times at the beginning. It's like, Ooh, uh, but there's something so great inside that because it's come, it's you embody, embody, embody, embody the texts. Like it's come like this. And when you act and you act for the first time in front of the camera, it's like you awake in the morning. It's so, but the text is awake, wake up, like, because I didn't know. Sometimes you look the language of your character, but maybe sometimes it's also exciting to look what's the language of the movie. Uh, when you saw other Amagushi movies, there's a, not a way to play, but a way to act. But there are some, sometimes also because he used non-professional actor. Sometimes we have something also very Bresson way, a very neutral way. And, but he's also a big fan of Casavetes, who was not this kind of acting, how to find the language of the movie. Uh, maybe we find it together. Like if you will concentrate, if you have a good preparation and you go inside this world, like a in between world, fiction, reality, documentary, cinema, you go inside that and you open to the other. I hope I opened myself to Tao, to, to the set is very, is also very attentive that, um, I don't know, the hairdresser don't come all the time. There is a large place for the actor. Then you find something and it starts, oh, that's the right way to do. It's not a right way to, it's never a white way to, to act or, uh, there's a, there's a lot of good way to do things. Um, but it's like a connection with everything and you find a precise sounds with the other. And Amagoshi got the perfect pitch. It's like that. We say, yes, he can hear your voice and say, no, you're not inside. But sometimes I was a little bit afraid also, because we make some in and interrupt to take 20 minutes and I have Japanese and French, you know, I was shoes only two months before the shooting and I must learn all the lines in Japanese. I, at the beginning, he asked me to learn, to, to read, uh, say too late to read, but I have all these texts, but it's, it's him. I say, okay, no problem. Uh, and then I have teacher, they learn to read Iragana. After that, I was so proud in Paris, everywhere. I say I can read Japanese, but I, I just, I, but I just can read one alphabet and there was three, then I read like an eight years old child. But that's amazing. I mean, it's real dedication. Yes, but what you, you are actor or yes, you know, if you have this kind of possibility, you take it. Ah, voila. And of course you walk. It's not, uh, no, it's not incredible. No, it was my dream to have this kind of thing. Maybe I don't happen the second time. Then of course I will, I will do it because he walks more than me. He also give us a document. It's a 17 question of the character and it's so well written, so well written, uh, so well written in his question. It's like a journalist question your character and ask him what's important for you in life. What's your relationship with sexuality? Nothing about the movie. Uh, but it's like you can know the secret of your character. It do, it do a lot of thing for you and then you want him to be happy because you, you think in this movie there's something important and I, then I'm so lucky to be here. Then of course, yes. Uh, yes, of course. And during two months I'm going to speak in Japanese all the time. And my husband would say, please. And my, and my son and my son name is Iro. Japanese name. Okay. To us this, uh, predestinate, but says also mama, what are you saying? Uh, but, but it's, I, so I'm so, so lucky for that. Yeah. Even I don't have this anymore. It exists. Hmm. Hmm. I think he was lucky to find you as, as the lead for the film. Um, I, um, you know, he's obviously a very visual director. We got scenes like the beautiful walking and talking scene when she and Marie leave after, after the experimental theater piece with Goro. Um, the lighting in that is so exquisite in the way they travel through these different pockets of, of outside Paris or, or I don't know if it's in Paris maybe. Yes, it's in Paris, but it's like a Paris, uh, so far from Emily in Paris, you know? Right. And also the beautiful, um, stuff on the hilltop in Kyoto that I just think is, is just the framing and the landscape to speak so loudly. It was the last scene that we should, we, we, he, he also make chronology, chronology, chronology, chronological, uh, uh, uh, but sometimes, you know, in Japan, uh, we don't have chronological, but this scene was the last one. And for me, you know, to do this thing, to say that to Tao, and yet there is also the sound of the train, like in, uh, in a Miyazaki movie. And it was normally when a film finish, yes, of course I've got an emotion, but it's normal. It must finish. We're going to do the shooting in six years. Okay. But when this finish do it, when this ends up, what was, Oh, Oh, I'm going to do. Yes. What I'm going to do now. Yeah. It's a hard act to follow this movie, but it's like, uh, okay. But I, I use the re the real relationship with Tao because we knew that we X, that we were experiencing something incredible. And when you also, that's, it will comes to an end, not so, so tragical that's in the movie fully, but, but we use that when I saw her, when I watch her, I've all that in my mind. When you, the, the film, this scene where you first meet, where you've found, um, Tomoki and you're up in the park and they come find you. And then the scene at the theater, were they the first things you shot with, with Tao? So you, during that walking in talking scene, you were, you were really getting to know her in the same way that Marie Lu is getting to know Marie. Yes. Yes. I mean, one of the things I find fascinating about Hamaguchi is that conversation is action for him. And so you talk about 20 minute takes. I know he likes very long takes, um, but 20 minute takes with that amount of dialogue. Did you ever go? No, never. But, uh, I was, okay. When you make a mistake in the text, it could happen. Uh, uh, we stop and we begin and we start to the beginning. Then at the beginning of this, I was a little bit, I must confess afraid because I say I must do it well. And if you have that in your mind, I must do it well. It's not a good way to be in the present. Then I must be kind to myself and say, Virginia, it's complicated and it's normal. It's not your language, but you're going to find a way. Just look at Tao. Don't think too much about yourself. You know, your text, you know, it's so you do it a hundred times. Everybody's, uh, tired about you for this, uh, hearing it. Okay. You know, everything new can be there. Yeah. And no, but I was never like this. I was, but I was so happy when, when I, when I, when I can hear, when I could hear that we have it because you, you know, we don't, it's not very expensive movie. We don't have a lot of day to do that. Then when you have the sun, the light is very important. The natural light is very important for him. Then we can do it a hundred and a hundred time and you, you must find a way, but it's also the possibility of leave really something to have long take like this. You're inside the things at the beginning of the first week of shooting. He's okay. Told me something in Japanese with a lot of emotion and the translator, the interpreter, interpreter told me, uh, I will introduce, it reduces, it translates what through the case says, and it's what I want you to find the light. Okay. And find the light is find, find, uh, find, um, receive things, receive all this material, be inside the things. He also told, told to me, also say to me, don't use your text like a tool. Just go inside your text. And at the beginning, you say, what's strange? What does it mean? It doesn't, it doesn't, there's no, there's no door to go inside the text. It's here. Okay. I can close. No, but you can feel when you are inside and maybe some people are going to say, I don't like it. And others say, Oh, it's good. That's not my problem. Me, I must be with the other really in the moment. And that may be something unexpected can come if you are like that. And normally it don't make any direction, don't give you direction, minimal direction. Yeah. No, I hate, and I'm a great, he hate psychological things. When Tao's asking way, but when you say you do that, you don't want this kind, just be in the present, just project. And it's, it's very intellectual, but after it's physical, physical things. Let's talk. We are going to run out of time, but just your impressions of Marie Lu as a woman, as a professional, she takes her job very seriously. She believes so passionately in the principles of humanitude. Despite the objections of some of her staff, including Sophie, who my favorite character in the movie. Oh, she's great. I didn't know she was in Chabrol film. Oh, wow. Amazing. But she's still, even though she's very much knows who she is, she's self-possessed as a woman. She's still open to other people's perspectives. I think increasingly so as the film goes on. And for me, one of the most moving things is the, I love all of the scenes where the caregivers talk to the patient's families, the little workshop scenes. Beautiful. And the one with Sophie, where you do the interview with her is incredible because both of you have had friction. You've both been at loggerheads. And yet by the end of that little chat, you're both looking at each other in a different way and understanding each other's sensitivity in a different way. And I think that's an amazing thing for a director and his actors to capture in a film without anything overtly emotional being stated. And that to me is part of the beauty of his films. But tell me a little about working with Tao, who plays Marie. How was that? So great. Like you said before, we met with this, we make during the movie, like the chronological things, we met each other progressively. And maybe we are, we were a little bit, we don't ask so much question about the other at the beginning, and maybe also to preserve something. And then after we became more and more closer. And what I like also in the Amaguchi approach is that it lets you free of thinking what you want. I think it's amazing that he filmed a relationship between two girls and the origin of the relationship is not desire or sexual things. But me, if I want during the scene when I smoke a cigarette, because it's a French film, Japanese, but also French. Compulsory, right? Yeah, exactly. When I smoke a cigarette, if I want to look at the neck of Tao and not the ground, I have this possibility. When she offers me a massage, I choose to make sounds. If a friend, not sexual friend, of a friend make me a massage, I don't do, I don't do this kind of sound. I don't know you, me, no. But it's, I choose to put something desire, but the movie is not about that. But me, as an actress, I have also my own secret, my own thoughts. And, but it's Amaguchi movie. But me, it's my character. And, and I never told, I never told him that. I never told him that. Just one month after the shooting, I told him, you know, sometimes I have this kind of thought with also maybe desire. And I say, if you have it, it's good. Yes, I think it's his movie and it's better that he do this like that. But me, I want to have that and also have physical things. It's okay. So we do have to finish, but just very quickly, the film talks about the vicious cycle of capitalism and the danger to democracy, societies collapsing, the exclusion of everyone, but the very wealthy and people, the poor working people being pushed further and further out of the cities. First of all, do you recognize the current world in that? And, but, and do you think there is hope? Because I think one of the big takeaways for the film, from the film, for me, is hope, even joy, you know, in places you don't expect it. Like the Tomoki and Kero scattering the ashes in Kyoto at the end. They're so joyful. It's such a beautiful moment. And so I feel like that is his, you know, his way of showing hope that there is a better future if we connect and listen to each other. Yes. Yes. Yes. Anyway, congratulations. But I have a political thing in my head and what happened in America just a few weeks ago. It's great. Yeah. That was great. Yes. The rest has been terrible. But okay. Okay. Everything. This is very good. Oh, maybe it's a hope. Yeah. And you can find a way for possible. Oh, to say that in Japanese, maybe. Yes. The impossible to possible. Yes. We must try. Goro says the impossible is impossible, but only until it becomes possible. So you think that is the essence of the film? Yes. But I like also, there's a lot of things, maybe the most important, but I like also what you say about the Marie character. And maybe it's also sometimes to understand, not understand, but listen to a person who don't think the same as you. Maybe sometimes don't vote like you, to don't say is the opposite. No, no. To try to find what we have in common and what we, and I like this thing because sometimes I don't know when you work on a character, if you are an actor, you also try to find similar thing with your own personality. And me, I have this kind of optimism. Okay. Everything is desperate, but, but I've also a little bit, how to say, difficult world in French is when you think you're right. Me, I felt it would be this kind of thing sometimes, but, and Marie-Lou too. Marie-Lou is a thing, she's, but no, maybe Marie, Sophie, thank you. Sophie had his own experience. He had his own experience and it's something you must listen to do that. You can make something collective, you don't listen to the other. All right. All right. I'm going to be shot if we keep going, but I mean, I could talk about this film for hours. Me also. Okay. So beautiful. Let's do it. Three hour movie and three hour Q and A. And the movie, the movie is in theaters, November 25th from Neon. So please, please send people to go see it. And I find it such a rewarding experience. And I've got to tell you, seeing it a second time, even more rewarding.